Jury Orders Xinyi to Pay Nearly $11 Million in Damages in Patent Infringement
A jury has ordered Xinyi Glass North America and Xinyi Automobile Glass
Co. Ltd. to pay nearly $11 million in damages to Saint-Gobain Autover
USA and parent company Saint-Gobain Sekurit for patent infringement. The
ruling came as the result of a suit filed by Saint-Gobain alleging that
Xinyi infringed on two of its patents, allege that Xinyi Glass North America
and Xinyi Automobile Glass Co. Ltd. infringed on two of its patents, one
titled “Spacer for Windshield Bracket” (known in court documents as the
‘669 patent) and one titled “Method of Centering Windshield Glazings”
(referred to as the ‘395 patent). The ruling came after a jury trial held
in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio in early
The jury awarded $10,944,015 total in compensatory damages—a breakdown
of $10,896,558 for lost profits and price erosion damages and $47,457
in royalty damages. They ruled that “Saint-Gobain proved by clear and
convincing evidence that Xinyi willfully infringed … the claims of the
‘395 or ‘669 patents.”
Both patents involve windshields equipped with “an extruded profiled spacer,”
according to a statement from Saint-Gobain Autover.
Witnesses in the case included industry expert Bob Beranek, Saint-Gobain
Autover representative Dennis Warlick, and several Xinyi representatives.
The original complaint was filed more than three years ago.
Novus, SuperGlass and Glass Doctor Rank High on Franchise 500®
Novus Glass, SuperGlass and Glass Doctor all received high rankings on
the recently released 2010 Franchise 500 list, published annually by Entrepreneur®
Savage, Minn.-based Novus Glass ranked at No. 89 on the list, up from
No. 83 in 2009. Novus also ranked at No. 68 on the list of fastest-growing
franchise, No. 24 on the low-cost franchise list, No. 24 on the home-based
franchise list and No. 73 on the list of America’s top global franchises.
Orlando, Fla.-based Superglass Windshield Repair was ranked No. 191—up
nearly 100 spots from No. 289 in 2009.
In addition to its ranking on the main list, SuperGlass ranked No. 47
on the low-cost franchise list, No. 55 on the list of top home-based franchises,
and No. 149 on the list of America’s Top Global Franchises.
Waco, Texas-based Glass Doctor rose 37 spots to No. 240 on the list, up
from No. 277 in 2009. In addition, the company ranked No. 75 on the list
of top home-based franchises and No. 179 on the list of America’s top
The Franchise 500 list is created based on a number of factors, including
financial strength and stability, growth rate and size of the company’s
franchising system, according to Entrepreneur. Rankings also take into
account a number of other items.
AGRSS Registration Helps Montana Glass Shop in Recent Case, Shop Owner
When Jeff Tribble, owner of J&D Auto Glass in Missoula, Mont., received
a call for a windshield replacement on a 1971 Mercedes, he knew his technician
had a bit of a drive ahead of him, as the job was about 90 miles away
from the company’s headquarters. But he likely didn’t expect what happened
“Once he cut the windshield out, he saw that there was a bunch of bathtub
caulking, rust and leftover bond from whoever put it in before, which
we later found out was a bodyshop,” says Tribble.
“He explained to the customer that it needed to go back to the bodyshop,”
Tribble told AGRR magazine/glassBYTEs.com™.
The technician left the vehicle there, sans windshield, and moved on—but
this wasn’t the last time he encountered the vehicle.
“We got a call from the gentleman who was paying for [the installation],
and he said we didn’t know what we were doing, and told us he was taking
us to court,” recalls Tribble. The customer sued the company for removing
the windshield and not replacing it.
The technician arrived in court with the removed windshield in-hand—and
some of the bathtub caulking he’d saved when he stripped it off of the
That part of the case lasted about 10 minutes, Tribble says, when the
judge saw what the technician showed him.
“We explained to the judge that we’re AGRSS-registered and that we can’t
install windshields under certain conditions,” Tribble says. He says they
also explained that the AGRSS Standard offers documentation that the installation
would have been unsafe, and the judge removed the charges against the
© Copyright 2010 Key Communications Inc. All rights reserved.
No reproduction of any type without expressed written permission.