A New York appeals court has upheld a financial judgment for Bear Glass Inc. in a dispute over unpaid window installations and alleged defective work at a commercial building in North White Plains, New York. Bear Glass is a glass and mirror fabricator based in Queens, New York.
The dispute centered on additional window installations approved by a property manager who lacked authority to authorize expenditures exceeding $1,000 without the building owner’s approval. Both the trial and appeals courts determined that Bear Glass reasonably believed the manager could approve the work, despite the owner’s objections to the additional charges.

Contract Dispute
According to court documents, the building’s owner, 901 Properties LLC, hired Bear Glass for $90,000 to replace windows at its commercial building. The agreement specified 177 windows, including 59 operable units; however, the project eventually involved 193 windows, including 100 operable units. 901 Properties maintained that the original agreement covered every window in the building. Bear Glass argued that the additional installations and modifications exceeded the original contract and warranted additional payment.
“The proposal, part of plaintiff’s exhibit one, was considered by the parties to be the contract,” reads the 2025 opinion from the Supreme Court, New York County. “Glaringly obvious from that document is that nowhere does it say ‘all windows’ or anything remotely similar. It says, ‘177 windows, 59 of which will have outswing awnings.’ If Jack Dweck [a principal of the plaintiff owner], an accomplished and experienced attorney, intended it to be all windows, then it was easy enough for him to add, somewhere, anywhere, that it covered ‘all windows.’ This brings the court to a credibility issue concerning the testimony of Dweck and the resident building manager, Charles Goh.”
The dispute also involved work approved by Goh, although court documents note that his management agreement prohibited him from authorizing expenditures exceeding $1,000 without the owner’s approval. The trial court found that Bear Glass reasonably believed he had authority to approve the changes. The judge determined that 901 Properties had instructed Bear Glass to work directly with Goh and that the contractor had no reason to question his authority.
The trial court ultimately sided with Bear Glass, awarding the company $62,400, plus interest.
Evidence Rejected
Alongside the contract dispute, 901 Properties sought $116,767.71 in damages, alleging that Bear Glass performed defective work, delayed the project and caused damage that required another contractor, Osman Ltd., to make repairs. However, the court found that 901 Properties failed to establish that the additional expenses resulted from Bear Glass’ work.
901 Properties submitted invoices and payment records but did not call anyone from Osman to testify about the repairs. The court also found that 901 Properties failed to provide sufficient firsthand testimony, photographs or other documentation connecting the alleged damage to Bear Glass.
The appellate court upheld the exclusion of the contractor’s invoices, finding that 901 Properties had not established the necessary foundation for their admission as business records. The judges also determined that the invoices did not identify window work or defects attributed to Bear Glass.
