by Thom Zaremba, shareholder at Roetzel & Andress

This is part one of a three-part blog.

What are the building codes doing to protect occupants from active shooters?

Between 2000 and 2017, the FBI reported 2,217 active shooter casualties in the United States. Violent shooters targeting our built environment have become a way of life in the U.S. It seems to have started as far back as 1966, when a lone gunman climbed to the top of a clock tower and rained rifle fire onto those at the University of Texas at Austin’s campus, killing 11 and wounding 21.

Locked entryways capable of resisting gunfire until first responders can arrive align with safer school design best practices. Courtesy of Technical Glass Products.

Fifty years later, in June of 2016, a gunman entered the Pulse Nightclub in Orlando and opened fire, killing 49 and wounding 53. The sheer number of mass killings and the prevalence of guns of every make and model in the hands of the public make it fair to ask whether—and, if so, what—are the building codes doing to make buildings safer from active shooters.

Shortly after the horrific Pulse Nightclub shooting, two of the principal code development bodies in the U.S. responded. In 2018, the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) responded and developed on an expedited basis its Standard for an Active Shooter/Hostile Event Response Program (NFPA 3000).

At about the same time, the International Code Council (ICC) convened an ad hoc committee on Building Safety and Security (ICC-BSS) to assess the safety and security measures employed in current building design and construction. Two years later, in 2020, the ICC-BSS issued its final report, concluding the work of the ad hoc committee.

Significantly, neither response by these prominent code development bodies proposed any changes to how to design or build safer buildings. Instead, NFPA’s response is a “how-to” guide for building owners and first responders to coordinate their efforts for an effective response when an active shooter event does occur. The ICC-BSS Report primarily intends to “stimulate thought, communication and future research on the topic of safety and security assessment among the multiple stakeholders ….”

So, why haven’t the code development bodies proposed any changes to their building codes that would make us safer from active shooters?

There are a lot of reasons.

  • Code development bodies do not typically propose changes to their own codes—that is left to interested industry and public-interest stakeholders like you and me.
  • A lack of consensus standards exists to provide a basis for the design and construction of building elements capable of protecting occupants from active shooters.
  • Criteria haven’t been developed, and certification bodies don’t yet exist capable of certifying risk assessment specialists competent enough to issue risk assessments for individual building designs capable of minimizing the risk of building entry by active shooters.

Historically, building codes have focused on things like the risks posed by fire, flammable materials, explosions and structural collapse, but not on gunmen targeting the building’s occupants. Accordingly, while their scopes all include protection of the building’s “means of egress” —i.e., how occupants get safely out of a building—their scopes say nothing that would permit stakeholders to address the building’s “means of ingress” —i.e., how to keep people with guns from getting into a building.

To keep active shooters out, a building would need to meet at least a few minimum requirements, including (i) those in the building would need a clear view of anyone approaching the building, (ii) that the entrance doors could be locked before a gunman enters and (iii) the locked entryway would need to be capable of resisting gunfire until first responders can arrive.

Although there are undoubtedly a variety of designs and materials capable of meeting these requirements, my obvious first choice is—you guessed it—glass!

In my next blog, we’ll explore a new ASTM Standard specifically developed to address construction materials capable of minimizing the risk of active shooters entering a building. We’ll also look at some code changes the glass industry will be proposing to change the scope of the building codes to address active shooters gaining access to our buildings and, specifically, to make our schools and classrooms safer from active shooters seeking to harm our children and their teachers.

1 Comment

  1. Agreed. Glass is a critical component of a Systems Approach to physical security! When the appropriate type of glass (acrylic, polycarbonate, actual-glass) is purposefully chosen, along with the proper framing, the risk of casualties is greatly mitigated. Our What is a Systems Approach to Ballistic Security article delves deeper into this topic. See it here: https://www.tssbulletproof.com/blog/what-is-a-systems-approach-to-ballistic-security

Comments are closed.