A house in Ohio exploded in October 2024, killing four people, allegedly due to the actions of a window replacement company. Photo: Unsplash.

A house in Ohio exploded in October 2024, killing four people, allegedly due to the actions of a window replacement company. The families of the deceased are now suing the company, Window World, and its local franchise for wrongful death.

The executors of the estates allege that during replacement work, Window World employees damaged the property of Jeffery and Joann Kocanyar, ultimately leading to the death of the couple, along with their daughter Julie Kocanyar Lubic and her husband, Adam Lubic.

Overview

According to court documents, Jeffery and Joann contracted Window World in 2024 for siding replacement on their home in Berlin Center, Ohio. The work was done on Oct. 4, 2024, the day after Julie and Adam Lubic arrived to visit Julie’s parents. During the work, neighbors “described hearing loud ‘banging’ and ‘hammering’ coming from the Kocanyar house,” the complaint says.

Documents indicate that at 4 p.m., “it was discovered that a water pipe in the basement of the Kocanyar home had broken, causing water to leak into the basement.” Additionally, the plaintiffs allege Window World employees failed to recognize that a propane gas line into the Kocanyar house had also been damaged during the work.

The damaged line led to the massive explosion on Oct.5, 2024, which killed all four occupants and three dogs. Pieces of the house were blown throughout the neighborhood.

Claims

Per the court documents, the executors of the estate claim four counts of wrongful death – negligence and four survival claims. The plaintiffs argue that the “direct and proximate result of the negligence, carelessness, and recklessness of the Window World defendants” caused the catastrophic explosion at the Kocanyar house and the “untimely deaths” of the four individuals.

In the counts for wrongful death – negligence, the plaintiffs argue that Window World “owed a duty to exercise reasonable care in the installation of exterior remodeling products, such as siding, on residential homes, including the Kocanyar home.”

Among the actions the complaint lists as negligent and careless include:

  • Damaging the propane gas line and, in turn, causing propane gas to enter the Kocanyar home;
  • A failure to exercise reasonable and proper care in the replacement and installation of siding on the Kocanyar home;
  • A failure to identify and/or remedy the propane gas leak and/or damage to the propane gas line; and
  • A failure to warn of the damage to the propane gas line and/or gas leak at the Kocanyar home.

The plaintiffs request “an amount in excess of $25,000, together with interest, costs, attorney’s fees, and other such relief ” per count of wrongful death and the same for each survival claim count. They’ve asked for a jury trial.